I think crack has some leeway, since it's unlikely to portray any serious subject matter in a way that reflects reality -- like, House going through withdrawal on House MD triggered the hell out of me, but a crackfic where Spock has to go through Chocoholics Anonymous would probably just make me *facepalmlol* like, um, most crackfics do.

Yeah, I followed a bunch of links from your link after responding, and headdesked repeatedly (or would have if I didn't have a lapfull of dog). When is it ever okay to question somebody's recounting of their traumatic experience?! Srsly, I wish rape/sexual abuse were uncommon enough that a story like that could be dismissed as far-fetched, but um, not even close. :(

(and yeah! I love that my new fandom is a lot of my friends' oldest fandom. Adorable story: one of my friends and his childhood bff dressed as Kirk and Spock for Halloween when they were 5.)